Help! I can't decide!

Okay, I need help. I received my first fix today from StitchFix. Stitchfix is a new company like Birchbox but with clothes. You pay $20 up front, fill out a style profile, enter your price range for each item and your sizes and they send you 5 items ranging from sweaters to skirts to accessories. You decide which items you want and send back what you don't in a pre-paid envelope. If you keep everything you get 25% off plus the $20 goes towards what you keep whether it's one item or five. 

I'll do a post on everything I got but for right now I'm trying to decide between the two items pictured above. The first is a black crepe circle skirt by Everly and is $45. I like the shape and surprisingly the length. It's longer than what I usually wear but I think that's why I like it. It has a very classy feel to it. The second item is the floral dress with belt by Lovposh and is $65. I love the material and the way it looks with the brown knee-high boots. So tell me, which looks better? Which one would you keep?